My teacher wonders if he’s wasting my time in the monthly private we have. I wonder if he is trying to tell me I’m wasting his time… I’m slow to move, low in confidence, lacking the perspective to sift through my confusions. Perhaps I’m missing the point in yoga? I feel mired in all the kleshas simultaneously. We’ll see how long he’s prepared to stand by while I find my way step by hesitant step. Or maybe I’ll blink first and quit the yoga show. One yogini, exit stage left.

But the comment from my teacher, if I take it at face value, raises interesting questions about the teaching and learning of yoga within my culture. J Brown again puts into words something I’ve been trying to articulate from my own small personal perspective. He suggests that the majority of people coming to class in the western world are after a feel-good fitness regime more than any kind of spiritual enlightenment or even personal growth. He characterises them as not being “willing to take on a radical inquiry into the nature of being, and having the courage to manifest what is discovered in attitudes and actions”. Because of this, he sees the teaching of modern yoga to be more about pleasing customers than passing on the wisdom of ancient cultures; it’s about ensuring students feel they are getting their money’s worth. Would my teacher raise his same concern to me if I wasn’t paying him for his time? And in this modern yoga relationship, which of us determines what I learn?

Because really we’re not students at all, we’re customers. We commonly use the language of study, but I don’t know many who practise yoga in such a dedicated way. We might show up to class regularly (many do every single day), we probably take a few workshops if they’re offered, but few of us take our yoga home and pursue it day after day. J Brown’s “radical inquiry into the nature of being” is a tall order.

Teaching my own class recently I found myself talking about yoga as a discipline. I don’t remember why. Trying to correct a general point of alignment? Maybe something about attention to detail, conscious movement, that ‘ease’ needs to be cultivated? I don’t know now… But I do remember feeling uncomfortable saying it, wondering if discipline was not quite the right word to use, if the concept would be an unwelcome one to my students. Most likely, as J Brown suggests, they were there just to stretch a bit and relax — not cultivate discipline, let alone that deeper inquiry into the very nature of things.

Now I wonder: if I don’t believe you can buy yoga, what am I selling? Only a year into teaching, I don’t want to develop such doubts about the Yoga ‘industry’ so soon. Where’s the honeymoon period of confidence and unshakeable enthusiasm, where the only worries are about playlists and fancy sequencing? Not heavy concerns about wisdom and integrity, and whether I have enough of either to share with others. Perhaps I’ll chat with J Brown for more perspective — he’s in London in January! 🙂

4 thoughts on “Crowdpleaser

Add yours

  1. My teacher talks about exactly this ALL the time. I would say about 1/4 to 1/3 of the people in the classes I attend are at least partially there for some level of self-exploration or personal development. While the style I study (Iyengar) isn’t conducive to the “gym mindset,” we aren’t completely immune to it, either. I can’t imagine what a struggle it is as a teacher to find the balance if your “customers” aren’t there to learn in the way yoga should (?) be taught.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Thanks for the comment Lynne. I always find it interesting to hear about Iyengar — such a different practice and teaching compared to the looser vinyasa style. I try not to assume too much about why my own students come to class. For myself my reasons for practising and attending classes seem to differ through time and life circumstances, so I realize I can never know what magic is going on inside my students. I just trust. And today (although I teach in a gym setting) we did a little Sanskrit chanting before a slower asana practice — some of them definitely liked it, but maybe not all… I just offered what I felt would be helpful at this hectic point in the festive season. Sometimes it feels great to have the choice in what I teach; other days, you’re right, it can feel a bit of a struggle.


  3. I’ve found over the years that just about everyone starts yoga as a form of exercise, but with reminders about detachment from results or letting go or watching their mind etc, they end up being interested in the philosophy as well to varying degrees. It’s funny, I always end my class with a Sanskrit prayer and thank the gurus. One evening I didn’t and a couple people asked me why. They really missed that part. You just never know what they’re getting out of it. You mentioned trusting- I think that’s important. Trust that those who come to you are getting what they need from you.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you Reena, that’s such a helpful comment to me. Indeed, you never know! My students constantly surprise me by their reactions — just shows I have much to remind myself about detachment from results or about bringing expectations! Thank you for sharing your experience too.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Website Built with

Up ↑

anonymous sadhaka

An Iyengar Yoga blog

Mimm Patterson

Yoga, Coaching & Craft

Phoenix Matarazzo

My life, in my words...


becoming a centenarian


a life worth living

Josephine Corcoran

never knowingly without a pen

Random Musings

A little bit of this, and a little piece of that!

Anthony Wilson

Lifesaving Poems


For whatever lights you up.

Beginner's Mind

Introduction to mindfulness, based in Huddersfield


Tales from the inner and outer world

Views from the Podium

A Blog. A Book. A Yoga Community.

Peregrine's Progress

Books, Cinema, Food, Photography, Theatre and Travel

Brooklyn Mellows

Coffee, Kirtan, Comics, Counterculture

Radical Yoga

with Colin Hall

The everyday vegetarian UK

Recipes, reviews and musings of a vegetarian in meat fuelled world


prose and poetry


Turning left up the road less travelled..

%d bloggers like this: